Did a flower grow in hell? Reading the modern history of Iran through the nonviolent participation of women in political struggles
Keywords:
civil resistance, Iran, women, feminism, nonviolenceCopyright (c) 2022 Sheida Besozzi
![Creative Commons License](http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by-nc-nd/4.0/88x31.png)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Abstract
This article’s objective is to place the modern history of Iran in relation to nonviolent struggles within the optic of the role of women within them, and to link these episodes with the feminist struggle in Iran. It will cover the years that span from the 1870s until 2021 by placing at the centre of the discussion the role of women in civil resistance struggles. Of particular interest will be national governmental changes, from the monarchic era to a theocratic republic; the presence of Britain and Russia, and later the United States; the mass mobilizations during the end of the nineteenth century and the Iranian Revolution; and gender equality campaigns, as well as more individual acts of resistance through cyber feminist campaigns. This paper aims to show the role of women in these struggles as interconnected with the Iranian feminist movement both inside Iran and in the diaspora.
Various episodes in Iranian modern history, such as the Tobacco Protests at the end of the 19th century, the Constitutional Revolution at the beginning of the 20th century and the Iranian revolution of 1979, as well as uprisings that preceded it between 1977 and 1979, have been studied within the civil resistance literature. All of these events showed that ordinary people had the power to topple authoritarian rule in their country through the use of nonviolent strategies. One of the most important references in nonviolent action studies, Gene Sharp, has suggested that 198 methods exist to efficiently overthrow dictatorial regimes around the world, and that these methods and techniques had to be collectively put into practice in order for them to be successful (Sharp, 1973, 2005). Various studies, mostly based on quantitative analysis and historical documentation, have demonstrated that nonviolent strategies have been in many instances much more successful than violence in achieving freedom from authoritarian rule (Chenoweth and Stephan, 2011; Chenoweth, 2021). In the Iranian socio-political context, the three aforementioned civil resistance struggles managed to establish a constitution and the creation of a parliament at the beginning of the 20th century, as well as the ousting of an autocratic leader in 1979. All of these episodes are considered to be examples of civil resistance techniques that have managed to topple the authoritarian regimes present at that time in Iran.
All of these struggles included the nonviolent participation of Iranian women, even though that participation has not sufficiently been brought to light in the Iranian history scholarship. The Tobacco Movement and the Constitutional Revolution represent the origins of a feminist conscience in Iran, and of women’s engagement with gender politics (Mahdi, 2004). Policies relating to women’s health, education, work and public life in general were present in both Pahlavi monarchies. However, whilst attempts were made to democratise the image of women, as well as their status, the Pahlavi regime did not achieved gender equality in Iran due to the strengthening of the class divide and its intensification by the persistent presence of British and American interests in the country.
With the installing of the Islamic regime in Iran in 1979, the advances in women’s rights that had been accomplished during the previous decades, thanks to the increased presence of women in public life, disappeared in the blink of an eye. The very many risks, nonetheless, have not prevented Iranian women from fighting for their rights through campaigns such as the One Million Signatures Campaign (1MSC) (2006-2009), or more recent internet gender campaigns such as My stealthy Freedom and White Wednesdays. Studies that have connected civil resistance struggles in Iran to women’s rights (see Beyerle, 2008; Davoudi Mohajer et al., 2009) have begun to pave the way for further developments and it is from this standpoint that the paper wants to make its contribution. The field of Resistance Studies where the subfield of civil resistance is located has been getting wider and deeper, incorporating different meanings and types of resistance acts, where collective as well as more individual stands have been taken into consideration. Poststructuralist, postcolonial and feminist outlooks have expanded the subfield of civil resistance, and the Iranian case clearly shows that the civil resistance scholarship can be applied to situations that involve the toppling of authoritarian regimes, internet gender equality campaigns, and also to those perspectives that take into consideration the transnational field. By placing attention on the links between nonviolent action and the Iranian feminist movement this article also shows the continuities and discontinuities of the participation of women in the civil resistance struggles in Iran, which in turn have to do with the different historical circumstances. As the paper will show, one key aspect has to do with the role of Iranian feminists in the diaspora who have supported and sometimes created civil resistance movements for gender equality in Iran. Sharp took the role of third parties into consideration (1973) within civil resistance movements, but it was not until Andrew Rigby’s study on the Palestinian diaspora and civil resistance (2009) that actors such as diasporas have been placed under increasing interest as supporters of civil resistance movements in their countries of origin (Dudouet, 2015; Stephan and Chenoweth, 2021).
Part 1 locates the arguments within a theoretical framework that links the subfield of nonviolent action with feminist perspectives from the fields of International Relations and Resistance Studies. Following this first section, the paper is divided into another five sections. Part 2 deals with the civil resistance struggles at the end of the nineteenth century and early twentieth century, as well as the role of women in them and the feminist movement. Next, part 3 of the article centres itself on the Pahlavi Monarchy that preceded the Islamic Revolution by looking at the position of women in Iran as well as the Iranian feminist movement. Part 4 looks at the nonviolent orientation of the Iranian revolution and the role of women therein, while part 5 locates the discussion on civil resistance within a more recent period and the conjunction with the Iranian diaspora. The article ends with a section dedicated to concluding remarks where future research lines will be suggested.
Downloads
References
Armanian, N. y Zein, M. (2012). Irán: La Revolución constante. Entre la modernidad y el Islam tradicional. Flor del Viento Ediciones.
Abrahamian, E. (2009). Mass Protests in the Iranian Revolution, 1977-79. En Roberts, A. y Garton Ash, T. (Eds.). Civil Resistance and Power Politics. The Experience of Non-violent Action from Gandhi to the Present. Oxford University Press.
Ackerman, P. y Duvall, J. (2000). A force more powerful. A century of nonviolent conflict. Palgrave.
Afary, J. (1992). The debate on women's liberation in the Iranian Constitutional Revolution. En Johnson-Odim, C. y Strobel, M. (Eds.). Expanding the boundaries of women's history: Essays on women in the third world (pp. 101-121). Indiana University Press.
Ahmadi, N. (2009). Iranian Women’s One Million Signatures. Campaign for Equality. The Inside Story. Women’s Learning Partnership.
Amin, C.M. (2002). The Making of the Modern Iranian Woman: Gender, state policy and popular culture, 1865-1946. University Press of Florida.
Arjomand, S.A. (1988). The Turbant for the Crown. The Islamic Revolution in Iran. Oxford University Press.
Baaz, M., Heikkinen, S. y Lilja, M. (2017). Resistance and Emotions Editorial. Journal of Political Power, 10 (2), 127-132.
Baaz, M., Lilja, M. y Vinthagen, S. (2017). Resistance Studies as an Academic Pursuit. Journal of Resistance Studies, 3 (1), 10-28.
Bartkowski, M. (2013). Recovering nonviolent history: Civil Resistance in Liberation Struggles. Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Bartkowski, M. (2015). Nonviolent Civilian Defense to Counter Russian Hybrid Warfare. The Johns Hopkins University Center for Advanced Governmental Studies.
Bayat, A. (2010). Life as Politics. How Ordinary People Change the Middle East. Stanford University Press.
Betteridge, A.H. (1983). To veil or not to veil: A matter of protest or policy. En Nashat, G. (Ed.). Women and Revolution in Iran (pp. 109-128). Westview Press.
Beyerle, S. (2008). Courage, Creativity, and Capacity in Iran: Mobilizing for Women’s Rights and Gender Equality. Georgetown Journal of International Affairs, 2 (9), 41-49.
Bill, J.A. (1988). The eagle and the lion: The tragedy of American-Iranian relations. Yale University Press.
Castañar, J. (2013). Teoría e historia de la revolución noviolenta. Virus Editorial.
Chabot, S. y Vinthagen, S. (2015). Decolonizing civil resistance. Mobilization: An International Quarterly, 20 (4), 517-532.
Chenoweth, E. (2021). Civil resistance. What everyone needs to know. Oxford University Press.
Chenoweth, E. y Ulfelder, J. (2017). Can Structural Conditions Explain the Onset of Nonviolent Uprisings? Journal of Conflict Resolution, 2 (61), 298-324.
Codur, A.M. y King, M.E. (2015). Women in Civil Resistance. En Kurtz M.M. y Kurtz L.R. (Eds). Women, War and Violence: Typography, Resistance and Hope (pp. 401-159). Praeger.
Davoudi, F., Toloui, R. y Beyerle, S. (2009). The Iranian Women’s Movement: Repression Versus Nonviolent Resolve. En Stephan, M. (Ed.). Civilian Jihad. Nonviolent Struggle, Democratization, and Governance in the Middle East (pp. 281-300). Palgrave MacMillan.
Dudouet, V. (2015). Sources, Functions, and Dilemmas of External Assistance to Civil Resistance Movements. En Schock, K. (Ed). Civil Resistance. Comparative Perspectives on Nonviolent Struggle (pp. 168-199). University of Minnesota Press.
Dudouet, V. (2017). Powering to Peace: Integrated Civil Resistance and Peacebuilding Strategies. ICNC Special Report Series, (1).
Fischer, M.M.J. (1982). Islam and the revolt of the petit bourgeoisie. Daedalus, 1 (111), 101-125.
Gentry, C.E. y Sjoberg, L. (2015). Beyond Mothers, Monsters, Whores. Thinking about women’s violence in Global Politics. Zed Books.
Goode, J.F. (1997). The United States and Iran: In the shadow of Mussadiq. Macmillan Press Ltd.
Halliday, F. (1979). Dictatorship and Development. Penguin.
Kazemi, F. y Abrahamian, E. (1978). The non-revolutionary peasantry of Modern Iran. Iranian Study, 1?4 (11), 259-304.
Keddie, N. (2013). Iran: Nonviolent Revolts, 1890-1906. En Bartkowski, M. (Eds.). Recovering nonviolent history: Civil Resistance in Liberation Struggles (pp. 1-30). Lynne Rienner Publishers.
López-Martínez, M. (2016). La resistencia civil examinada: de Thoreau a Chenoweth. Revista Latinoamericana, 43 (15), 41-65.
McCarthy, R. y Kruegler, C. (1993). Toward Research and Theory Building in the Study of Nonviolent Action. The Albert Einstein Institution.
Magallón, C. (2006). Mujeres en pie de paz. Siglo XXI.
Mcguinnes, K. (1993). Gene Sharp’s Theory of Power: A feminist Critique of Consent. Journal of Peace Research, 1 (30), 101-115.
Mahdi, A.A. (2004). The Iranian Women’s Movement: A century Long Struggle. The Muslim World, (94), 427-448.
Matin-Asgari, A. (2002). Iranian student opposition to the Shah. Mazda Publishers Inc.
Moghadam, V.M. (1997). Gender and revolutions. En Forad, J. (Ed.). Theorizing Revolutions (pp. 142-171). Routledge.
Mujika Chao, I. (2017). Women’s organisations of Kosovo in civil resistance and peacebuilding (1989-2014). Theoretical relations and influence of the international cooperation (Tesis doctoral). Universidad del País Vasco.
Nashat, G. (1980). Women in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Iranian Studies, 1-4 (13), 165-194.
Nashat, G. (1983). Women in Pre-Revolutionary Iran: a Historical overview. En Nashat, G. (Ed.). Women and Revolution in Iran (pp. 5-35). Westview Press.
Nasirpour, S., Barlow, R. y Akbarzadeh, S. (2022). Iran’s Feminist School in the Diaspora: Dynamics of Decline and Demobilization. Development and Change, 0 (0), 1-24.
Novak, A. y Khazraee, E. (2014). The Stealthy Protester: Risk and the Female Body in Online Social Movements. Feminist Media Studies, 6 (14), 1094-1095.
Rigby, A (2009). ‘Diasporas: Potential partners in struggle’. En Clark, H. (Eds.). People Power. Unarmed Resistance and Global Solidarity (pp. 177-183). Pluto Press.
Ritter, D. (2015). The Iron cage of Liberalism. International Politics and Unarmed Revolutions in the Middle East and North Africa. Oxford University Press.
Sameh, C. (2014). From Tehran to Los Angeles to Tehran: Transnational Solidarity Politics in the One Million Signatures Campaign to End Discriminatory Law. Women’s Studies Quarterly, ¾ (42), 166-188.
Sazegara, M. y Stephan, M. (2009). Iran’s Islamic Revolution and Nonviolent Struggle. En Stephan, M. (Ed.). Civilian Jihad. Nonviolent Struggle, Democratization, and Governance in the Middle East (pp. 185-204). Palgrave MacMillan.
Schock, K. (2005). Unarmed Insurrections. People Power Movements in Nondemocracies, Social Movements, Protest, and Contention. University of Minnesota Press.
Schock, K. (2015). Introduction: Civil Resistance in Comparative Perspective. En Schock, K. (Ed). Civil Resistance. Comparative Perspectives on Nonviolent Struggle (pp. 1-23). University of Minnesota Press.
Scott, J.C. (1989). Everyday Forms of Resistance. The Copenhagen Journal of Asian Studies, 4, 33-62.
Shahidian, H. (1994). The Iranian Left and the “Woman Question” in the Revolution of 1978-79. International Journal of Middle East Studies, 2 (26), 223-247.
Shahri, S. (2001). Women in Command: A successful experience in the National Liberation Army of Iran. En Waller, M. R. y Rycenga, J. (Eds.). Frontline Feminisms: Women, war and resistance (pp. 183-190).Garland Publishing.
Sharp, G. (2005). Waging Nonviolent Struggle. 20th Century Practice and 21st Century Potential. Extending Horizons Books, Porter Sargent Publishers.
Shepherd, L.J. (2020). Narrating the Women, Peace and Security Agenda. Logics of Global Governance. Oxford University Press.
Stephan, M.J. y Chenoweth, C. (2008). Why Civil Resistance Works. The Strategic Logic of Nonviolent Conflict. International Security, 1 (33), 7-44.
Stephan, M.J. y Chenoweth, C. (2021). The Role of External Support in Nonviolent Campaigns. Poisoned Chalice or Holy Grail? ICNC Press.
Zunes, S. (2009). The Iranian Revolution (1977-1979). ICNC Press.