The abandoned minor and the coder. A reflection on the performativity of family law
Keywords:
Family Law, Minor, Codification, PerformativityCopyright (c) 2022 Raquel Medina Plana
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Abstract
Coming from the field of the philosophy
of language, the notion of performativity
has, in the field of law, a critical
push, by problematizing the notion
of the determination of the subjects of
rights. Codification, a paradigmatically
performative stage in itself, reaches its
maximum creative expression in the field
of family law, around this new paterfamilias
endowed with almost unlimited
power in the cognatic family that is his
own. The institutions of adoption and
guardianship, at the crossroads of these
tensions, provide an exceptional starting
point to explore these operations of performance
of legal subjects, objects and
rights. The situation of the helpless minor,
in which a double marginalized condition
intersects, both in terms of assets
and blood ties, will be radically modified.
Downloads
References
Butler, J., “Sovereign performatives», en Excitable speech. A politics of the performative,
(edición en español, «Soberanía y actos performativos», www.
accpar.org/numero4/index.htm);
Butler, J., Laclau, E., y Zizek, S., Contingencia, hegemonía y universalidad. Diálogos
contemporáneos en la izquierda, Buenos Aires, 2003.
Caroni, P., Lecciones de historia de la codificación, Madrid 2013.
Latour, B., 2004: “Scientific objects and legal objectivity”, en Pottage y Mundy
(eds.) Law, Antrophology, and the constitution of the social. Making persons and
things, Cambridge, 2004.
Medina Plana, R., La adopción en los albores de la codificación civil: procesos de
circulación y redistribución de expósitos en la Inclusa de Madrid, siglos XVIII-XIX,
Madrid, 2015.
Medina Plana, R., “Tutela y adopción en España. Leyes, cambios y prácticas, siglos
XVIII y XIX”, en García Gonzalez F. y Alfaro Pérez, F. (eds.) Vidas tuteladas.
Familias, orfandad y dependencia en la España Moderna. Ed. Trea, Madrid, 2022.
Petit Calvo, C. Un Código perfecto y bien calculado: el proyecto de 1821 en la historia
de la codificación, Madrid, 2019.
Pottage, A., “Introduction: the fabrication of persons and things”, en Pottage y
Mundy (eds.) Law, Antrophology, and the constitution of the social. Making persons
and things, Cambridge, 2004.
Supiot, A., Homo juridicus. Ensayo sobre la función antropológica del derecho, Buenos
Aires, 2005.