“It is not my objective to be metaphoric or allegorical”: history, counter-history, and antisemitism in Philip Roth’s «The Plot Against America»
Keywords:
Philip Roth, antisemitism, history/counter-history, Lindbergh, RooseveltCopyright (c) 2024 Gustavo Sánchez Canales
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Abstract
After Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America (2004) came out he published “My Uchronia” (2004). Among other things, Roth explains that before reading Arthur M. Schlesinger’s A Life in the 20th Century (2000) he “had no such novel in mind” (2017: 341). This autobiography made him think of what would have happened if Charles A. Lindbergh—the famous aviator and Nazism supporter—had won the 1940 elections instead of F.D. Roosevelt. In this essay, which abounds in the theme of antisemitism introduced in a previous paper (Sánchez Canales, 2021), I will focus on the factual figure of Lindbergh—and to a lesser extent that of his wife Anne Morrow—Roth’s counter-versions of them, and key factual and counterfactual events depicted in the narrative. Through this comparative analysis I will attempt to show that Roth’s fictional America is by no means something far-fetched.
Downloads
References
Beilis, Mendel (1926): The Story of My Sufferings, New York, Mendel Beilis Publishing Co., Inc.: https://ia601400.us.archive.org/4/items/in.ernet.dli.2015.89442/2015.89442.The-Story-Of-My-Sufferings_text.pdf (accessed: 19/03/2024).
Bellow, Saul (1989): The Bellarosa Connection, New York, Penguin Books.
Berg, A. Scott (1998): Lindbergh, New York, Berkley Books.
Boese, Stephanie (2014): «‘Those Two Years’: Alternate History and Autobiography in Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America», in Studies in American Fiction, 41, 2: 271-292: 10.1353/saf.2014.0013 (accessed: 01/04/2024).
Brinkley, Alan (2010): Franklin Delano Roosevelt, Oxford and New York, Oxford University Press. «FDR Campaigns For Re-election» (2013), in History Central: https://archive.ph/20130125203751/http://www.historycentral.com/FDR/FDR_1940Election.html (accessed: 31/03/2024).
Gourevitch, Philip (2018): «Aharon Appelfeld and the Truth of Fiction in Remembering the Holocaust», in The New Yorker: https://www.newyorker.com/culture/postscript/aharon-appelfeld-and-the-truth-of-fiction-in-remembering-the-holocaust (accessed: 15/03/2024).
Grafton, John (ed.) (1999): Franklin Delano Roosevelt. Great Speeches, Mineola, New York, Dover Publications, Inc.
Gross, Andrew S. (2010): «It Might Have Happened Here: Real Anti-Semitism, Fake Story, and Remembering the Present», in Amerikastudien/American Studies, 55,3: 409-427.
Hertog, Susan (1999): Anne Morrow Lindbergh. Her Life, New York, Doubleday.
Ivanova, Velichka D. (ed.) (2011): Reading Philip Roth’s American Pastoral, Toulouse, Presses Universitaires du Mirail.
Ivanova, Velichka D. (2010): Fiction, utopie, histoire. Essai sur Philip Roth et Milan Kundera, Paris, L’Harmattan.
Joyce, James (1993): Ulysses, Oxford & New York, Oxford University Press.
Kaplan, Brett Ashley (2011): « ‘Just Folks Homesteading’: Roth’s Doubled Plots Against America», in Shostak, Debra (ed.) (2011): 115-129.
Kauvar, Elaine (2011): «My Life As a Boy: The Plot Against America», in Shostak, Debra (ed.) (2011): 130-144.
Kellman, Steven G. (2008): «It Is Happening Here: The Plot Against America and the Political Moment», in Philip Roth Studies, 4, 2: 113-123: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5703/philrothstud.4.2.113 (accessed: 01/04/2024).
Malamud, Bernard (1966): The Fixer, New York, Farrar, Strauss and Giroux.
Maurer, Yael (2011): «‘If I Didn’t See It with My Own Eyes, I’d Think I Was Having a Hallucination’: Re-Imagining Jewish History in Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America», in Philip Roth Studies, 7, 1: 51-63: 10.1353/prs.2011.a430870 (accessed: 01/04/2024).
McKinley, Maggie (ed.) (2021): Philip Roth in Context, Cambridge & New York, Cambridge University Press.
Morley, Catherine (2008): «Memories of the Lindbergh Administration: Plotting, Genre, and the Splitting of the Self in The Plot Against America», in Philip Roth Studies, 4,2: 137-152: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5703/philrothstud.4.2.137 (accessed: 01/04/2014).
Neelakantan, Gurumurthy (2021): «The ‘Philip Roth Books’», in McKinley, Maggie (ed.) (2021): 101-110.
Parrish, Timothy (2011): «Autobiography and History in Roth’s The Plot Against America», in Shostak, Debra (ed.) (2011): 145-160.
Prager, Dennis; Joseph Telushkin (2016): Why the Jews? The Reason for Antisemitism, the Most Accurate Predictor of Human Evil, New York, Touchstone.
Roosevelt, Franklin Delano (2009): Looking Forward, New York, Touchstone.
Roth, Philip (2017): «My Uchronia», in Philip Roth: Why Write? Collected Nonfiction 1960-2013, New York, The Library of America: 336-345.
Roth, Philip (2004): The Plot Against America, Boston & New York, Houghton Mifflin Company.
Samuel, Maurice (1966): Blood Accusation: The Strange History of the Beiliss Case, Philadelphia, Jewish Publication Society.
Sánchez Canales, Gustavo (2021): «Antisemitism», in McKinley, Maggie (ed.) (2021): 241-251.
Sánchez Canales, Gustavo (ed.) (2019): Literature and Genocide. Verbeia, Madrid, Universidad Camilo José: https://journals.ucjc.edu/VREF/issue/view/244 (accessed: 19/03/2024).
Sánchez Canales, Gustavo (2019): «Introduction», in Sánchez Canales, Gustavo (ed.) (2019): 1-23. https://journals.ucjc.edu/VREF/article/view/4128/3020 (accessed: 19/03/2024).
Sánchez Canales, Gustavo (2011): «‘There Is a Bomb Blast in the Most Elegant Greek Revival House’: Classical Motifs in Philip Roth’s American Pastoral», in Ivanova, Velichka D. (ed.) (2011): 205-217.
Sánchez Canales, Gustavo (2009): «The Classical World and Modern Academia in Philip Roth’s The Human Stain», in Philip Roth Studies, 5, 1: 111-128: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5703/philrothstud.5.1.111 (accessed: 19/03/2024).
Sánchez Canales, Gustavo (2008): «Necessity Freed Spinoza and Imprisoned Yakov: The Presence of Spinoza’s Ethics in Bernard Malamud’s The Fixer», in Icfai Journal of English Studies, 3,1: 7-15: https://www.iupindia.in/308/IJES_Freed_Spinoza_and_Imprisoned_Yakov_7.html (accessed: 29/03/2024).
Sánchez Canales, Gustavo (2006): «Bernard Malamud’s Russian Background in The Fixer», in Mundo eslavo, 5: 46-54: https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=2771975 (accessed: 29/03/2024).
Scanlan, Margaret (2021): «The War on Terror», in McKinley, Maggie (ed.) (2021): 333-343.
Schiffman, Dan (2009): «The Plot Against America and History-9/11», in Philip Roth Studies, 5, 1: 61-73: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5703/philrothstud.5.1.61 (accessed: 01/04/2024).
Schlesinger, Arthur M., Jr. (2002): A Life in the 20th Century, Innocent Beginnings, 1917-1950, Boston, Mariner Books.
Schlesinger, Arthur M., Jr. (1958): The Coming of the New Deal: 1933-1935 (The Age of Roosevelt), Boston, Mariner Books.
Shostak, Debra (2011): «Introduction», in Shostak, Debra (ed.) (2011): 111-114.
Shostak, Debra (ed.) (2011): Philip Roth: American Pastoral, The Human Stain, The Plot Against America, New York, Continuum International.
Siegel, Jason (2012): «‘The Plot Against America’: Philip Roth’s Counter-Plot to American History», in MELUS, 37, 1: 131-154: https://www.jstor.org/stable/41440716 (accessed: 01/04/2024).
Sokoloff, Naomi (2006): «Reading for the Plot? Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America», in AJS Review, 30, 2: 305-312: https://www.jstor.org/stable/4131667 (accessed: 01/04/2024).
Toker, Leona (2013): «Between Dystopia and Allohistory: The Ending of Roth’s The Plot Against America», in Philip Roth Studies, 9, 1: 61-73: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5703/philrothstud.9.1.41 (accessed: 01/04/2024).
Trendel, Aristi (2018): «The Tribulations of American Democracy in Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America», in Baltic Journal of English Language, Literature and Culture, 8: 120-128: https://journal.lu.lv/bjellc/article/view/376/359 (accessed: 01/04/2024).
Volkman, Ernest (1982): A Legacy of Hate. Anti-Semitism in America, New York, Franklin Watts.